Author name: J. Chadwick Schnee

Blog

OOR: Agency Must Show It Actually Incurred Prior RTKL Fees Before Withholding New Requests (Perlmutter v. Yardley Borough)

By J. Chadwick Schnee, Esq. November 18, 2026 Legal Insights with Attorney Schnee Can an agency refuse to process new Right-to-Know requests because the requester still owes copying fees from earlier ones? Under Commonwealth Court precedent, it can. But a new Office of Open Records final determination holds that the agency must first show it […]

Blog

Commonwealth Court: Generic Privilege Log Is Not Enough; OOR Must Review Governor’s Office Pages In Camera (Haverstick v. Office of the Governor)

By J. Chadwick Schnee, Esq. November 16, 2026 Legal Insights with Attorney Schnee A privilege claim under the Right-to-Know Law has to rest on facts, not labels. In Matthew Haverstick and Kleinbard LLC v. Pennsylvania Office of the Governor (Office of Open Records), No. 1407 C.D. 2025 (Pa. Cmwlth. Nov. 16, 2026), an unreported memorandum

Blog

Pennsylvania Supreme Court Declines Review in Ferretti: Ancestry.com’s Scans of State Archives Records Stay Outside the RTKL

By J. Chadwick Schnee, Esq. November 13, 2026 Legal Insights with Attorney Schnee The Pennsylvania Supreme Court will not take up the fight over Ancestry.com’s digitized copies of State Archives records. In a one-line per curiam order in Pennsylvania Historical & Museum Commission v. Ferretti (Office of Open Records), Nos. 247 and 248 MAL 2026

Blog

OOR: Alcoa and Arconic Lose Trade Secret and Security Claims Without Evidence; UCC Shields Only Building Records (Cirilano v. Upper Burrell Township)

By J. Chadwick Schnee, Esq. November 12, 2026 Legal Insights with Attorney Schnee When a company steps into a Right-to-Know appeal to protect its own information, it takes on the job of proving the exemption, and a position statement is not proof. In Cirilano v. Upper Burrell Township, OOR Dkt. AP 2026-2755 (Final Determination issued

Blog

OOR: School District Cannot Charge Requester for Email Conversion Software Bought Before Fee Notice (Ulisky v. Franklin Area School District)

By J. Chadwick Schnee, Esq. November 11, 2026 Legal Insights with Attorney Schnee An agency may sometimes recover costs it necessarily incurs to fulfill a Right-to-Know request, but timing and notice matter. In Ulisky v. Franklin Area School District, OOR Dkt. AP 2026-4445 (Final Determination issued Nov. 10, 2026), the Office of Open Records held

Blog

OOR: Proposals From Cancelled DHS Community HealthChoices Solicitation Are Not Exempt Procurement Records (Sher v. Department of Human Services)

By J. Chadwick Schnee, Esq. November 10, 2026 Legal Insights with Attorney Schnee The Right-to-Know Law protects bidders’ proposals while a Commonwealth procurement is still open, but that protection does not last forever. In Lawrence Sher and Winston Taylor, LLP v. Pennsylvania Department of Human Services and Direct Interest Participants, OOR Dkt. AP 2026-3409 (Final

Blog

Commonwealth Court Quashes Sunshine Act Appeal Over Unvoted Litigation Reversal as Interlocutory (Bethlehem Landfill Co. v. Lower Saucon Township)

By J. Chadwick Schnee, Esq. November 9, 2026 Legal Insights with Attorney Schnee A Sunshine Act lawsuit can raise serious questions about how a governing body reached a decision, but the challenger still has to follow the appellate rules to get those questions in front of the Commonwealth Court. In Bethlehem Landfill Company v. Lower

Blog

OOR: Philadelphia Sheriff Must Unredact Unclaimed-Check List Beyond Tax Refunds; Fiscal Code Does Not Block Access (Herndon v. Philadelphia Sheriff’s Office)

By J. Chadwick Schnee, Esq. November 6, 2026 Legal Insights with Attorney Schnee Lists of unclaimed city checks and sheriff-sale surplus often sit at the intersection of the Right-to-Know Law (RTKL), tax confidentiality statutes, and the Fiscal Code’s rules for people who recover abandoned property. A new Final Determination works through those layers with care.

Blog

Commonwealth Court: Governor Must Release Security Consultant Email and Redacted Report After Arson Attack Review (Osborne v. Office of the Governor)

By J. Chadwick Schnee, Esq. November 5, 2026 Legal Insights with Attorney Schnee Security exemptions under the Right-to-Know Law (RTKL) are real, but they are not a blank check. In an unreported memorandum opinion filed November 4, 2026, the Commonwealth Court reversed the Office of Open Records (OOR) and ordered the Pennsylvania Office of the

Scroll to Top