Commonwealth Court: Sharing a Police Report With a Civil Adversary Does Not Waive the RTKL’s Criminal Investigation Exemption (Perry v. Pennsylvania State Police)
Legal Insights with Attorney Schnee
On October 19, 2026, in Perry v. Pennsylvania State Police (Office of Open Records), No. 764 C.D. 2025, a three-judge panel of the Commonwealth Court affirmed a Final Determination of the Office of Open Records (OOR) upholding the Pennsylvania State Police’s (PSP) denial of a request for a 58-page criminal incident report. In an unreported memorandum opinion by Judge Stacy Wallace, the Court held that the report was exempt in full under the Right-to-Know Law’s (RTKL) criminal investigation exemption, Section 708(b)(16), and that its release is also barred by the Criminal History Record Information Act (CHRIA). Along the way, the Court rejected a series of arguments that requesters and agencies see often: that sharing a record with someone else waives an exemption, that the agency had to redact rather than withhold, that the OOR had to review the record in camera, and that the denial letter was not specific enough.
The request
On April 4, 2025, Shakia Perry asked PSP for “a complete and unredacted copy of the investigative report identified as PA 2024-476258,” concerning a title investigation involving a vehicle previously titled in New Jersey and reissued a clean title in Pennsylvania without a record of a lien. She specifically sought “all internal reports, communications, officer notes, correspondence with PennDOT, and any final determinations or flags.”
The agency’s response
On April 11, 2025, PSP mailed an extension letter under Section 902(b)(2). On May 12, 2025, PSP denied the request under Section 708(b)(16), the personal identification exemption in Section 708(b)(6)(i)(A), and CHRIA, supported by a verification from its Deputy Agency Open Records Officer, who attested that he personally examined the report and found it to be “manifestly related to a criminal investigation.” Ms. Perry appealed to the OOR. Among other things, she argued that PSP offered no redactions, no privilege log, and no page-level analysis, and that PSP had disclosed the same record to her adversary in civil litigation.
On appeal, PSP submitted a verification from its Agency Open Records Officer describing the record as a 58-page report, including attachments, compiled by two troopers after PennDOT asked PSP to investigate a possible fraudulent titling of a 2019 Mercedes sedan. When Ms. Perry disputed receiving the extension letter, the OOR asked PSP for a copy, which PSP provided the next day. The OOR then offered the parties more time to supplement the record, and Ms. Perry objected, stating, “I agree the current record is sufficient for review.” In Perry v. Pennsylvania State Police, OOR Dkt. AP 2025-1431 (June 12, 2025), the OOR denied the appeal under Section 708(b)(16).
The issues
On review, the Court addressed whether the OOR denied Ms. Perry due process, including by accepting PSP’s extension letter and declining in camera review; whether PSP waived the exemption by sharing the report with a third party; whether PSP had to redact the report or exercise its discretion to release it; whether the denial letter satisfied Section 903(2); whether CHRIA independently barred release; and whether PSP acted in bad faith.
The ruling
No due process violation. The Court explained that due process in RTKL appeals requires notice and an opportunity to present evidence, and that appeals officers have wide procedural discretion. Ms. Perry filed several position statements and conceded that the record was sufficient, so the OOR did not err in excluding her later submissions as cumulative. The Court also noted that a requester “is not entitled to rebuttal for the sake of having the last word.” PSP’s extension letter was mailed within five business days of receipt of the request, so PSP properly claimed the 30-day extension under Section 902(b).
In camera review. The Court stated that the OOR has discretion to review records in camera, “particularly for purposes of ascertaining a claim of privilege,” but that the OOR cannot compel an agency to produce investigative information protected by CHRIA. Because PSP relied on Section 708(b)(16) and CHRIA rather than any privilege, the Court concluded that “OOR has no authority to conduct an in camera review” on this record.
Prior disclosure is not a waiver. Ms. Perry argued that, by giving the report to her civil adversary, PSP could not withhold it from her. The Court disagreed: “Nothing within Section 305 conditions exemption on prior nondisclosure.” Section 506(c) gives an agency discretion to release an exempt record that is not privileged, and the Court held that “allegations of past disclosure by PSP do not constitute waiver for RTKL exemption purposes.” For the same reason, PSP could not be compelled to exercise its Section 506(c) discretion in Ms. Perry’s favor, because that section “allows but does not require” an agency to release exempt records.
No redaction or page-level log required. Relying on its precedent that police incident reports are investigative materials under Section 708(b)(16)(ii), and that the entire investigative report is exempt where the exemption applies, the Court held that PSP did not have to redact the report. Absent evidence of bad faith, the sworn verifications had to be accepted as true, and the credible affidavit of a PSP open records officer was sufficient. The denial letter also met Section 903(2) because it identified the exemptions relied on and cited supporting legal authority. The RTKL does not require the “redaction” or “page-level” analysis Ms. Perry sought.
CHRIA. Although the OOR had not addressed PSP’s CHRIA argument, the Court held that the report is “investigative information” under CHRIA, which prohibits PSP from disseminating it to anyone other than a criminal justice agency.
No bad faith. PSP timely claimed the extension, issued a timely denial, conducted a good faith search, and promptly answered the OOR’s request for the extension letter. The Court also explained that the reviewing court, not the OOR, has authority to impose costs, fees, and penalties for bad faith under Sections 1304 and 1305. The OOR’s reference to a second, incorrect report number on the first page of its Final Determination was treated as a typographical error that did not affect the outcome.
Verification note. At one point the opinion cites “65 P.S. § 67.706(b)(16)” for the rule that an entire investigative report is exempt; the exemption is in Section 708(b)(16), and the surrounding discussion makes clear that is the provision the Court applied.
A second October 19 decision: contractor personnel records
The same day, in Pew v. Department of Corrections (Office of Open Records), No. 1037 C.D. 2025, a different panel, in an unreported memorandum opinion by Judge Christine Fizzano Cannon, affirmed the OOR’s denial of an inmate’s request for letters of reprimand concerning a doctor who worked at SCI-Phoenix for Wellpath, a Department contractor. The OOR, in Pew v. Pennsylvania Department of Corrections, OOR Dkt. AP 2025-1907 (Aug. 5, 2025), had reasoned that the letters did not directly relate to Wellpath’s governmental function under Section 506(d) and that the RTKL “does not enable requesters to audit contractors’ internal personnel files.” The Court did not reach Section 506(d). Instead, it held that a contractor performing a governmental function stands in the agency’s shoes and may invoke Section 708 exemptions, and that any letters of reprimand fit “clearly within” the exemptions for written criticisms of an employee and information regarding discipline contained in a personnel file, Sections 708(b)(7)(vi) and (viii). Because Wellpath raised Section 708(b)(7) before the OOR, the argument was not waived. (The opinion’s citation at one point reads “65 P.S. 67.708(b)(vi), (viii)”; the quoted text is from Section 708(b)(7).)
Takeaway
Perry is unreported, so it is not binding precedent, but it may be cited for its persuasive value, and it collects several practical rules in one place. For agencies, the decision confirms that a detailed, sworn verification from an open records officer who actually reviewed the record can carry the burden under Section 708(b)(16), that a denial letter citing the exemptions and supporting authority satisfies Section 903(2), and that sharing an investigative record with another person does not by itself waive the exemption. Agencies should still remember that the five-business-day window to claim an extension is strict, and that proof of a timely extension letter may be requested on appeal. For a refresher on those timelines, see our guide to Pennsylvania RTKL response and appeal deadlines.
For requesters, Perry is a reminder to think carefully before telling the OOR that the record is complete, because that concession weighed against Ms. Perry’s later due process arguments. A requester who is in civil litigation with someone who already has a copy of a PSP report may have other avenues, such as civil discovery, but under Perry the fact that someone else received the record does not, on its own, change its status under the RTKL. Requesters should also note that the Court tied in camera review to privilege claims, and found no authority for it where PSP relied only on Section 708(b)(16) and CHRIA. For another recent decision on PSP investigative records, see our post on Rodriguez v. Pennsylvania State Police.
Pew adds a point for contractors and the agencies that hire them. Even where a contractor’s records are reachable under Section 506(d), the contractor can raise the same exemptions an agency could, including the personnel-record exemptions in Section 708(b)(7), and it should raise them before the OOR so they are preserved.
Schnee Legal Services, LLC is based in Lititz, Pennsylvania, and represents individuals, municipalities, and businesses throughout the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania in Sunshine Act and Right-to-Know matters. Learn more about Pennsylvania RTKL representation or visit schneelegal.com (book a consultation at schneelegal.cliogrow.com/book). Phone 717.400.5955, chadwick@schneelegal.com.
This post is for informational purposes only and is not legal advice. Using this website does not create an attorney-client relationship. Email may not be private; do not email confidential information.
Have a request or an appeal of your own?
Business-day clock and appeal package, all in one docket.