Pennsylvania Right-to-Know Law · Decisions & analysis
RTKL Decisions
Pennsylvania Right-to-Know final determinations
County DA Appeals OfficerPhiladelphia County

David Butler v. Philadelphia District Attorney's Office: Final Determination

Philadelphia DA Appeals Officer Peter F. Andrews held that even confirming whether misconduct investigation records on a detective exist would reveal a criminal investigation.

David Butler asked the Philadelphia District Attorney’s Office whether records exist of cases under review, allegations, referrals or criminal investigations involving improper interrogation conduct by a named Philadelphia detective between 1998 and 2010. Appeals Officer Peter F. Andrews held that all of the requested records are criminal investigative records under 65 P.S. § 67.708(b)(16), and rejected Butler’s argument that he sought only confirmation that the records exist: revealing whether records of a criminal investigation exist would itself reveal the institution of a criminal investigation. He declined to rest the ruling on the Office’s separate argument that the law does not require agencies to answer questions, and dismissed the appeal. He noted that the decision addresses only whether the records are public records under the Right-to-Know Law, not whether the Commonwealth must disclose favorable evidence to a defendant under Brady v. Maryland, a duty that continues through post-conviction proceedings. Further appeal lies with the Philadelphia County Court of Common Pleas within 30 days under 65 P.S. § 67.1302.

Key citations

65 P.S. §§ 67.503(d)(2), 67.708(b)(16); Coley v. Philadelphia District Attorney's Office, 77 A.3d 694 (Pa. Cmwlth. 2013); Pennsylvania State Police v. Grove, 161 A.3d 877 (Pa. 2017)

Open Docket

Facing a denial like this? Track your request and appeal deadline with Open Docket.

Business-day clock and appeal package, all in one docket.

Start a request in Philadelphia County →

Full decision

Download the decision PDF

Need help with a RTKL matter? Received a denial like this one? Schnee Legal Services, LLC represents individuals, municipalities, and businesses in Right-to-Know requests and appeals. Get help. This summary is provided for general information only and is not legal advice. Using this website does not create an attorney-client relationship.

New DA Appeals Officer decisions, weekly.

One email, each week: new county determinations, summarized and linked to the source.

Unsubscribe anytime.

Scroll to Top