Edward Peterson of Lemoyne, PA sought the CID investigation file generated in response to a private criminal complaint he had submitted to the DA’s Office in May 2018. Peterson correctly cited the RTKL’s carve-out protecting private criminal complaints themselves from the §708(b)(16) exemption. However, First Assistant DA Matthew P. Smith — a different appeals officer than Hair LaRue, who had issued the initial denial — sustained the denial on second review, drawing a careful distinction: the file sought was not the private criminal complaint itself, but the full criminal investigation that followed it. That investigation file remained exempt under §708(b)(16)(ii) even though no charges were ultimately filed, and even after the investigation concluded.
Key citations
Barros v. Martin, 92 A.3d 1243 (Pa. Cmwlth. 2014) Lambert v. Office of Attorney General, 2015 WL 5254070 (Pa. Cmwlth. 2015)
Facing a denial like this? Track your request and appeal deadline with Open Docket.
Business-day clock and appeal package, all in one docket.
Full decision
Need help with a RTKL matter? Received a denial like this one? Schnee Legal Services, LLC represents individuals, municipalities, and businesses in Right-to-Know requests and appeals. Get help. Using this website does not create an attorney-client relationship. See our Disclaimer.