Pennsylvania Right-to-Know Law · Decisions & analysis
RTKL Decisions
Pennsylvania Right-to-Know final determinations
Appeals OfficerLegislative Budget and Finance Committee

Howard E. Klein v. Legislative Budget and Finance Committee: Final Determination

Dr. Howard E. Klein requested LBFC documentation, minutes, communications, and participant information related to an ongoing House Resolution 60 study of beneficial use of sewage sludge / biosolids by land application. LBFC denied because the materials were not “legislative records” and also cited § 708(b)(17). After an OOR transfer to LRB, Appeals Officer Duane M. Searle denied the appeal: pre-report study materials are not enumerated legislative records (unlike final LBFC reports), the audit work-papers exemption does not apply, but § 708(b)(17)(ii) noncriminal investigative materials does. LBFC was not required to take further action. FLAG: LRB §503(c) legislative-agency FD.

Key citations

65 P.S. §§ 67.101 et seq. (RTKL); 65 P.S. § 67.102, 67.303(a), 67.305(b), 67.503(c)(1), 67.708(a)(2), 67.708(b)(17)(ii), 67.708(b)(17)(v), 67.901, 67.902, 67.1102(a)(2), 67.1301(a); Dep’t of Health v. Office of Open Records, 4 A.3d 803 (Pa. Commw. Ct. 2010); Dep’t of Pub. Welfare v. Chawaga, 91 A.3d 257 (Pa. Commw. Ct. 2014)

Open Docket

Facing a denial like this? Track your request and appeal deadline with Open Docket.

Business-day clock and appeal package, all in one docket.

Start a Pennsylvania request →

Full decision

https://rtkldecisions.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/09/klein-2016-lbfc.pdf

Source: https://www.palrb.gov/Right-To-Know-Appeals. Getfile: https://www.palrb.gov/getfile.cfm?file=resources/RTK/appeals/2016%20-%20Klein%20v.%20LBFC.pdf&view=true. Local path before upload: /workspace/case-cards/lrb-appeals/pdfs/klein-2016-lbfc.pdf.

Need help with a RTKL matter? Received a denial like this one? Schnee Legal Services, LLC represents individuals, municipalities, and businesses in Right-to-Know requests and appeals. Get help. Using this website does not create an attorney-client relationship.

New Appeals Officer decisions, weekly.

One email, each week: new Appeals Officer determinations, summarized and linked to the source.

Unsubscribe anytime.

Scroll to Top