Pennsylvania Right-to-Know Law · Decisions & analysis
RTKL Decisions
Pennsylvania Right-to-Know final determinations
Legal InsightsBlog

OOR: Bank Routing Numbers on Agency Checks Are Public; Account Numbers Stay Redacted (Harris v. DCED)

OOR AP 2026-3236 (Oct. 1, 2026): DCED may redact bank account numbers under RTKL 708(b)(6), but bank routing numbers on grant payment checks are public and must be disclosed; bad faith declined.

Legal Insights with Attorney Schnee

In James Harris v. Pennsylvania Department of Community and Economic Development, OOR AP 2026-3236 (Final Determination issued October 1, 2026), Appeals Officer Lyle Hartranft granted in part, denied in part, and dismissed as moot in part an appeal over ARPA H2O, RACP, and Local Share Account grant records. The practical holding for open-records officers is narrow but useful: personal financial information such as bank account numbers may be redacted under Section 708(b)(6), but bank routing numbers on agency checks are public and must be disclosed.

The request and response. On July 2, 2026, Harris asked DCED (and, as framed, the Commonwealth Financing Authority) for applications, scoring sheets, award letters, payment records, and related materials for three Indiana County-area grants: a December 19, 2023 ARPA H2O award to the Central Indiana County Joint Sanitary Authority, a $5 million RACP pipeline grant, and a roughly $997,139 Local Share Account demolition grant. After a thirty-day extension, DCED produced about 798 pages, asserted it did not possess RACP records, and redacted personal identification information, including what it treated as personal financial information on checks.

On appeal, Harris challenged the RACP nonexistence claim, the remaining redactions (signatures, email addresses, phone numbers, and financial fields), sought in camera review, and asked for a bad-faith finding under Section 1304. DCED submitted an attestation from interim open records officer Candace Gaul and, during the appeal, provided less-redacted records that restored signatures.

The ruling. First, records produced with fewer redactions during the appeal mooted that slice of the dispute. Second, DCED met its burden that additional RACP records are not in its possession: the attestation explained that the Redevelopment Assistance Capital Program is administered at the Office of the Budget, that grant leadership confirmed DCED does not house those files, and that the open records officer’s Section 901 search turned up nothing further. The OOR declined in camera review because the existing record was enough to decide the issues.

Third, on redactions, Section 708(b)(6)(i)(A) and the Section 102 definition of “personal financial information” allow redaction of bank account information and related personal finance fields. Gaul attested that the contested financial fields were checks with bank account information redacted. That kind of account data may stay withheld. But routing numbers are different. Citing Monaghan v. Lycoming County, OOR Dkt. AP 2025-3834, Appeals Officer Hartranft explained that bank routing numbers are public because banks publish them and hold them out to the public. To the extent DCED’s redactions covered routing numbers, those numbers must be disclosed. The Department was ordered to provide the responsive records with bank routing numbers unredacted within thirty days.

Fourth, the OOR declined a bad-faith finding. DCED issued a timely final response, produced a large volume of records, and participated on appeal. Bad faith under the RTKL is reserved for egregious or blatant violations; only a court may impose the related penalties.

Takeaway. When an agency produces cancelled checks or similar payment images, do not treat the entire MICR line as one exempt block. Account numbers and similar personal financial information can be redacted under Section 708(b)(6). Routing numbers generally cannot. Requesters challenging “financial” redactions on grant payment records should ask specifically whether routing numbers were blanked. Agencies that house only part of a multi-agency grant stack still need a documented Section 901 search, but they are not required to pull another Commonwealth agency’s program files when those records live elsewhere and the requester can ask that agency directly.

Schnee Legal Services, LLC is based in Lititz, Pennsylvania, and practices throughout the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania. For Pennsylvania Right-to-Know Law and Sunshine Act matters, visit About Pennsylvania RTKL Representation, schneelegal.com, or book a consultation. Phone: 717.400.5955. Email: chadwick@schneelegal.com.

This post is for informational purposes only and is not legal advice. Using this website does not create an attorney-client relationship. Email and other electronic communications may not be private.

Open Docket

Have a request or an appeal of your own?

Business-day clock and appeal package, all in one docket.

Start or track your RTKL request with Open Docket →

New decisions and commentary, weekly.

One email, each week: new Appeals Officer determinations and blog posts, summarized and linked to the source.

Unsubscribe anytime.

Scroll to Top