Pennsylvania Right-to-Know Law · Decisions & analysis
RTKL Decisions
Pennsylvania Right-to-Know final determinations
Legal InsightsBlog

Pending RTKL Bills: New Exemptions, Broader Coverage, and Harder Requests in the 2025-2026 Session

Legal Insights with Attorney Schnee

Update (October 21, 2026): SB 1150 passed the House 182-21 on October 21, 2026 without amendment and now goes to the Governor. See our post on the House vote and the official bill page.

A quiet midweek for new Commonwealth Court and Supreme Court Right-to-Know or Sunshine opinions, and a docket of OOR final determinations that mostly restated settled denial and nonexistence patterns, is a good moment to look upstream. The Pennsylvania General Assembly’s statute-reference list for acts amending the Right-to-Know Law shows a live stack of bills that would change Section 708 exemptions, who counts as a covered entity, how hard a request may be, what agencies may charge, and what happens if someone destroys records under request. This post scores the substantive set along two axes: whether the bill would increase or decrease public transparency, and whether it would make it easier or harder for agencies to respond to RTK requests. Links below are to current printers-number text on palegis.us.

Bills that expand coverage or accountability (more transparency).

Senate Bill 226, Printer’s No. 179, passed the Senate on May 12, 2025, and sits in the House Intergovernmental Affairs and Operations Committee. It amends the Section 102 definition of “State-affiliated entity” to add the Pennsylvania School Boards Association and the Pennsylvania Interscholastic Athletic Association. Those entities would then sit inside the RTKL’s Commonwealth-agency framework for State-affiliated entities. On the transparency axis, that is an increase: more organizations with public educational and athletic roles would face the same request and appeal structure. On the agency-response axis, it increases workload for the newly covered entities, which would need open-records officers, five-business-day clocks, and exemption proof rather than arguing they are outside the statute.

Senate Bill 686, Printer’s No. 755, passed the Senate on June 4, 2025, and was re-referred to House Commerce on December 15, 2025. The current printers number strikes the original draft that would have created a freestanding RTKL Section 1305.1 felony and instead amends Crimes Code Section 4911(b): tampering with public records stays a second-degree misdemeanor unless the record is the subject of a current RTKL request or appeal, or the actor intends to defraud or injure, in which case the offense is a third-degree felony. Transparency increases because destruction or alteration of records under active RTKL process would carry felony exposure. Agency response capacity is largely unchanged for lawful processing; the bill raises the cost of unlawful impairment rather than rewriting search or exemption duties.

House Bill 834, Printer’s No. 864 would add Section 701(c) requiring monthly online posting of financial records dealing with fund disbursements, quarterly Auditor General affirmations, periodic audits, and a private civil action for declaratory, injunctive, or mandamus relief with possible attorney fees. That increases proactive transparency and increases agency compliance burden outside the ordinary request-response cycle. It remains in House Intergovernmental Affairs and Operations (referred March 10, 2025).

House Bill 91, Printer’s No. 74 would amend Section 708(b)(17)’s lead-in so the noncriminal-investigation exemption applies to “a record of an agency, except for the Pennsylvania Fish and Boat Commission.” Read as drafted, Fish and Boat could not invoke (b)(17). That would increase transparency for that Commission’s noncriminal investigative files and would make response harder for Fish and Boat on those records (other exemptions could still apply). Status: referred to House Game and Fisheries on January 14, 2025.

House Bill 279, Printer’s No. 227 raises the Treasury contract-filing threshold from $5,000 to $10,000, makes contract summaries mandatory, and adds semi-annual notice, attestation, public posting of noncompliance, and payment-hold leverage. Transparency of Commonwealth contracts would improve at the summary and attestation layer even as the dollar trigger moves up. Agency filing burden increases. Status: referred to House Intergovernmental Affairs and Operations on January 23, 2025.

Bills that add or widen exemptions (less transparency; often easier agency refusals).

House Bill 802, Printer’s No. 830 is the furthest along among new-exemption measures: House final passage March 24, 2026 (199-0), referred to Senate State Government on March 30, 2026. It expands Section 708(b)(12) so notes and working papers used “to assist an individual with a disability,” including transcriptions, braille translations, or large-print materials, are exempt, and it adds Section 708(b)(31) for records that would disclose the identity of a claimant or victim in an executed settlement of a sexual harassment or sexual assault claim, with a matching financial-record redaction cross-reference in Section 708(c). Transparency decreases for those discrete categories. Agency response becomes easier on disability-accommodation work product and settlement-identity fields because the statute would supply a clear withhold/redact path instead of patchwork privacy arguments.

House Bill 1789, Printer’s No. 2199 broadens the Section 102 definition of “personal financial information” (W-2s, benefit elections other than specified retirement membership elections, retirement and health-contribution detail, charitable contributions, and other personal-finance information), clarifies that Section 708(b)(6) does not block disclosure of employer or aggregated benefit costs or benefit options offered to employees, and adds Section 708(b)(31) protecting agency bank routing, account, credit-card, and PIN numbers with mandatory redaction to protect account security, plus a Section 708(c) financial-record redaction hook. Net effect: less transparency into individual benefit elections and agency payment credentials; clearer permission to redact those fields, which eases lawful agency response on check images and similar financial records. Status: referred to House Intergovernmental Affairs and Operations on August 10, 2025.

House Bill 1899, Printer’s No. 2369 extends Section 708(b)(6)(i)(C)’s home-address exemption from law enforcement officers and judges to members of the General Assembly. Narrow transparency decrease; modest ease for legislative and agency responders holding member residential data. Status: referred September 30, 2025, to House Intergovernmental Affairs and Operations.

House Bill 1907, Printer’s No. 2384 amends Section 506(b)(1) disaster/damage denials to cover State Archives materials available under PHMC policies, expands Section 708(b)(24) from “library and archived materials” to library, archives, and museum materials and rare collections subject to donor limits, adds Section 708(b)(31) for third-party digital reproductions, indices, metadata, and work product even when the agency possesses them (unless the third party agrees in writing), and adjusts Section 1307(b)(2) fee language for historical duplication. Transparency decreases for digitized third-party work product and some archival categories; agencies gain clearer grounds to deny or fee historical and third-party digital sets. Status: referred September 30, 2025, to House Intergovernmental Affairs and Operations.

Bills that reshape request burden and fees (harder for some requesters; easier for agencies to narrow or monetize).

House Bill 868, Printer’s No. 904 would add Section 708(b)(31) exempting “[r]ecords that are reasonably burdensome in their scope for an agency to produce,” keep Section 1307(h) prepayment when estimated fees exceed $100 (tied to new subsection (i)), and create Section 1307(i) allowing additional reasonable advance fees for requests intended for for-profit entities or for-profit activities, with a five-business-day fee notice, purpose inquiries, and an exemption for newspapers, magazines, broadcast outlets, and similar organizations. That is a substantial transparency decrease for commercial and large-scope requesters and a substantial increase in agencies’ ability to refuse or price out burdensome and for-profit demand. Status: referred March 11, 2025, to House Intergovernmental Affairs and Operations.

House Bill 974, Printer’s No. 1057 would change Section 703 so a request “must” (not “should”) identify records with sufficient specificity, and would let the open-records officer weigh, in that specificity determination, the burden of a full Section 901 good-faith review and redaction within statutory deadlines, potential privacy or proprietary harm if that review cannot be finished in time, and federal or state disclosure penalties. Transparency decreases at the front door; agency ability to deem a request insufficiently specific increases. Status: referred March 19, 2025, to House Intergovernmental Affairs and Operations.

Sunshine companion bills (already in the Blog conversation; status only).

Separately from the RTKL statute, House Bill 2146, Printer’s No. 2882 (House final passage July 1, 2026; Senate State Government as of July 9, 2026) and Senate Bill 1150, Printer’s No. 1399 (Senate final passage June 10, 2026; House final passage, 182-21 without amendment, October 21, 2026; awaiting the Governor’s action) would narrow post-*Coleman* majority-vote agenda additions under Sunshine Act Section 712.1. Both increase meeting transparency by limiting last-minute official action; they increase procedural burden on boards that have relied on open-ended agenda additions. They do not amend the RTKL itself.

Takeaway. The pending RTKL file is not one-directional. SB 226 and SB 686 push outward (more covered entities; felony-grade tampering when records are under request). HB 802, HB 1789, HB 1899, HB 1907, HB 868, and HB 974 push inward (new or broader exemptions, burdensomeness, for-profit fees, and specificity factors). For open-records officers, the practical watch list is HB 802 in the Senate, SB 226 and SB 686 parked in the House, and the House Intergovernmental package that would change how hard a request may be before the agency ever reaches Section 708. None of these bills is law until enacted; always check the current printers number on palegis before advising a client or rewriting a municipal RTKL policy.

Schnee Legal Services, LLC is based in Lititz, Pennsylvania, and represents individuals, municipalities, and businesses throughout the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania in Sunshine Act and Right-to-Know matters. Learn more about Pennsylvania RTKL representation and visit schneelegal.com. Book a consultation at schneelegal.cliogrow.com/book. Phone 717.400.5955. Email chadwick@schneelegal.com.

This post is for informational purposes only and is not legal advice. Using this site does not create an attorney-client relationship. Email may not be private; do not email confidential information.

Open Docket

Have a request or an appeal of your own?

Business-day clock and appeal package, all in one docket.

Start or track your RTKL request with Open Docket →

New decisions and commentary, weekly.

One email, each week: new Appeals Officer determinations and blog posts, summarized and linked to the source.

Unsubscribe anytime.

Scroll to Top