Robert Spurgeon asked the Bucks County District Attorney’s Office for DNA work-up and results from his criminal case, which he said a university forensic laboratory produced for county and local police and the Pennsylvania State Police. The Appeals Officer received his appeal on December 26, 2023. Appeals Officer Eugene Tsvilik denied the appeal because the office does not possess the records. The Open Records Officer affirmed he could not locate them, an agency need not create records (Section 705), and the office made the good faith effort Section 901 requires. Spurgeon also failed to address the grounds for the denial as Section 1101 requires. Tsvilik rejected the argument that CHRIA and the criminal investigative exemption no longer applied because the case was closed, because CHRIA does not distinguish between open and closed or charged and uncharged cases. Even if the office had the records, he wrote, CHRIA would bar releasing them. Any further appeal was to the Bucks County Court of Common Pleas within 30 days under Section 1302.
Key citations
65 P.S. §§ 67.705, 67.901, 67.1101, 67.1302; CHRIA, 18 Pa.C.S. §§ 9102, 9106(c)(4)
Facing a denial like this? Track your request and appeal deadline with Open Docket.
Business-day clock and appeal package, all in one docket.
Full decision
Need help with a RTKL matter? Received a denial like this one? Schnee Legal Services, LLC represents individuals, municipalities, and businesses in Right-to-Know requests and appeals. Get help. This summary is provided for general information only and is not legal advice. Using this website does not create an attorney-client relationship.